The Wine Atlas

Angel's Envy: The Bottle, the Port Finish and the Price

In this guide
Wooden whiskey barrels resting on racks in a distillery warehouse

Angel's Envy is the tall, long-necked bottle with the wings on the glass, and it is one of the most recognized shapes on a bourbon shelf. Both expressions we carry come in the 750ml: the port-finished bourbon and the rye finished in Caribbean rum casks.

Most people who look this bottle up want three things answered. What the finish actually does, which of the two to buy, and where it stands on a kosher table. All three below.

The bottle

It is a deliberately unusual shape for the category. Tall, clear, a long tapered neck, and a pair of wings worked into the glass itself rather than printed on a label. Most Kentucky bourbon comes in a squat, square, heritage-looking bottle. Angel's Envy went the other way, and the bottle is a large part of why people photograph it and why they remember the name.

The name comes from the angel's share, the whiskey that evaporates out of the barrel while it ages. The pitch is that this one is good enough that the angels would want the rest of it too.

The two bottles, side by side

Bottle Finish Alcohol Price
Angel's Envy Bourbon Port wine casks 43.3% See today's price
Angel's Envy Rye Caribbean rum casks 50% See today's price

What a cask finish actually does

Bourbon has to be aged in new charred oak. That is in the rules, and it is why all bourbon shares a vanilla and caramel backbone. A finish is what happens after that: the whiskey comes out of its bourbon barrel and goes into a second barrel that previously held something else, for a stretch at the end.

The second barrel is not neutral. Wood holds onto the liquid that soaked into it, and the whiskey pulls some of that back out. Port casks give dried fruit, fig and a raspberry-ish sweetness. Rum casks give molasses, brown sugar and a tropical lift. It is a layer added on top of a finished whiskey rather than a change to how it was made.

Angel's Envy Bourbon

A small-batch Kentucky straight bourbon from Louisville, started by the late Lincoln Henderson and his son Wes, finished in port wine casks. Bottled at 43.3%.

Amber in the glass, with vanilla bean, honey, toasted oak, dried fig and that raspberry note from the port on the nose. The palate is smooth and medium-full: vanilla, caramel, dark cherry, and a warm oak spice that lingers. The finish is long, plush and gently sweet.

The honest description is a classic Kentucky bourbon wearing a port cloak. The bones underneath are familiar. What the finish adds is fruit and a softness that makes it an easy pour for someone who normally finds bourbon too hot.

Drink it neat in a Glencairn, or over one large cube, or build a top-shelf Old Fashioned with orange peel. It also makes a serious Manhattan.

Angel's Envy Rye

A 95% rye rested up to eighteen months in authentic Caribbean rum casks and bottled at 100 proof. The higher strength matters here. The rum sweetness rounds every edge, and without that extra alcohol behind it the whiskey would go soft.

Brown sugar, vanilla and baking spice on the nose with a thread of tropical fruit. On the palate the rye's pepper is still there but it has been softened by molasses, honey and rum-cask sweetness. Long, warm, gently sweet finish.

Rye spice in a Panama hat is about right. Sip it neat to see what the rum casks did, or make it the showpiece in a tiki-leaning Old Fashioned.

If the rye and bourbon distinction is the part you are unsure about, we wrote it up plainly in rye vs bourbon.

Which of the two

Buy the bourbon if you want the famous one, the softer pour, and the bottle people recognize. Buy the rye if you already drink rye and want something genuinely odd, because a rum-finished 100 proof rye is not a flavor you can get anywhere else on the shelf.

The kosher question, straight

This is the part to read before you buy. Both Angel's Envy bottles are cask-finished in barrels that held wine or rum, and neither carries a hechsher. A port cask held wine, and wine is a kosher question in a way that oak is not. The same applies to the rum cask.

We are not going to tell you it is fine. Ask your rav before pouring either of these on a kosher table. Plenty of people hold one way on cask finishes and plenty hold another, and that is a question for your own rabbi and not for a wine shop. How to read a whiskey label for yourself is in is your whiskey kosher and our kosher liquor guide.

What else ninety dollars buys

Angel's Envy Bourbon port finished
Boondocks 6 Year Port Finish port finished
Basil Hayden no finish
Woodford Reserve no finish
Bulleit Kentucky Straight Bourbon no finish

Worth knowing that Boondocks 6 Year Port Finish does the same trick for half the money, and it is the bottle to try first if the port finish is the part you are curious about rather than the name. Bulleit is the straight-ahead Kentucky reference point, and we wrote it up in the Bulleit guide.

The bottom line

Angel's Envy Bourbon is a well-made, fruit-lifted Kentucky bourbon in a bottle that earns its shelf space, and the rum-cask rye is the more unusual of the two. Both are uncertified because of the finishing casks, so settle that question with your rav first. The rest of the shelf is in our bourbon collection.

Free shipping on orders $150+ in the lower 48.