Stranahan's Colorado Whiskey: Both Bottles, and What American Single Malt Means

Stranahan's is whiskey from Denver, Colorado, and it is one of the bottles people search for by name and then struggle to find a straight answer about. Here is the straight answer: two bottles on our shelf, both 47% alcohol, both American single malt, both carrying OU on the listing.
That last phrase is the part worth understanding, because American single malt is a young category and it is not what most people assume when they see the words "single malt" on a label.
What American single malt actually means
Single malt means two things and only two things. Single means one distillery. Malt means the grain is 100% malted barley. It does not mean one barrel, it does not mean Scotland, and it does not mean old.
Scotland got the reputation, so most people hear "single malt" and think Speyside. But nothing in the definition is Scottish. Barley is barley. We laid out the Scottish side of this in single malt vs blended Scotch.
The American difference is the wood. Scotch is usually aged in barrels that held something else first, bourbon or sherry, so the oak gives a secondhand, mellowed flavor. Stranahan's goes into new charred American oak, which is the bourbon rule. New oak is loud. It gives caramel, vanilla and char fast and hard.
Put those two together and you get the point of the whole category: the malty, cereal, bready body of a single malt, carrying bourbon's sweet charred-wood signature. It tastes like neither parent, which is why it is worth trying even if you already know what you like.
Stranahan's Colorado Original
Stranahan's Colorado Original is the one to start with, and one of the first American single malts to get taken seriously. 100% malted barley, distilled in Denver, 47%.
The nose is caramel, malted cereal, ripe banana and a touch of oak char. The palate runs sweet malt, vanilla, dried apricot and warm baking spice. Medium-long finish with toasted oak and a faint smoke behind it.
Banana is the giveaway note. If you have had a young Speyside you will recognize it. The difference is how much sweeter the new oak makes everything around it.
Good with smoked salmon canapés, or a square of milk chocolate after a meal.
Stranahan's Diamond Peak
Diamond Peak is the Original turned up. A blend of the distillery's finest single-malt barrels at four years old, named for a Colorado peak over 14,000 feet. Same 47%.
Toasted oak, dark caramel, dried fig and clove on the nose. Richer malt on the palate with brown sugar, candied orange and warming spice. The finish is long, deep and gently oaky.
Four years is young by Scotch standards, where a 12 year old is the entry bottle. Colorado does not play by those numbers. Denver sits at over 5,000 feet, the air is thin and dry, and the barrel breathes harder and faster than it does in a damp Scottish warehouse. A Colorado four year old has taken more out of the wood than the number suggests.
This is the after-dinner bottle, and the better of the two as a gift.
Which one
| Bottle | Price | ABV | The job |
| Colorado Original | See today's price | 47% | Learn the category. Sweet, malty, approachable. |
| Diamond Peak | See today's price | 47% | Sip it slowly. Deeper, darker, a present. |
Buy the Original first. If you finish it and want more of the same idea with more weight behind it, that is what Diamond Peak is for. There is no reason to start at the top here.
How to drink it
Neat, in a glass that narrows at the top, at room temperature. A few drops of water open it up and are not a sin. Ice is fine if that is how you enjoy it, but 47% carries plenty of flavor and the cold will shut some of it down.
Do not mix it. At this price there are better bottles to put in a cocktail, and the malt character is the whole reason you bought it.
Where else single malt comes from
Colorado is not the only answer outside Scotland, and the rest of the shelf is a useful comparison:
- M&H Elements Red Wine Cask. Israeli single malt from Tel Aviv, finished in red wine casks.
- Starward Solera. Australian, matured in fortified wine barrels.
- Hakushu 12 Year. Japanese, light and faintly smoky.
- Glengoyne 10 Year. The Scottish control test at exactly the Stranahan's price.
Put the Glengoyne next to the Colorado Original at the same money and the new-oak difference is obvious in one sip. That is the cheapest way to understand what American single malt is doing.
Is Stranahan's kosher?
Both Stranahan's bottles record OU on their listing, which is unusual on the whisky shelf. Most single malts carry no symbol at all. We went through the whole question in is your whiskey kosher, and if Passover is the concern, that is a separate answer: neither Stranahan's bottle is kosher for Passover.
Browse the rest in Stranahan's, the wider whiskey and spirits shelf, or see where everything sits on price in how much is a bottle of whiskey.
Free shipping on orders $150+ in the lower 48.


