The Wine Atlas

The Sexton Irish Whiskey: Single Malt in the Black Bottle

In this guide
A whiskey bottle and a filled glass on a wooden table beside hazelnuts

You have probably seen it without knowing the name: a matte black hexagonal bottle, more apothecary than distillery, sitting on the shelf between the Jameson and the Scotch. That is The Sexton, and it is one of the better-value Irish single malts going: a sherry-matured malt that drinks like a bottle twice the price.

What The Sexton actually is

It is an Irish single malt. Three words that each do work:

  • Single: everything in the bottle comes from one distillery.
  • Malt: made from 100% malted barley, no other grain, no neutral spirit.
  • Irish: distilled and matured in Ireland, in this case in County Antrim, up in Old Bushmills country on the north coast.

It is triple distilled, which is the Irish habit and the reason Irish whiskey tends to land softer and rounder than Scotch, and it spends four years in European oak ex-Oloroso sherry butts: big casks that previously held sweet fortified Spanish wine. That cask choice is the whole character of the whiskey. Bottled at 40%.

It is blended by Alex Thomas, one of the few women working as a master blender in Irish whiskey, and the brand sits under Proximo Spirits. The hexagonal bottle is a nod to the basalt columns of the Giant's Causeway, which is up the road from where it is made.

About that name

A sexton is the caretaker of a church: the one who rings the bell, keeps the grounds and digs the graves. It is a deliberately solemn, slightly gothic name, and the black bottle and the funeral-director typeface are all pulling in the same direction. It is marketing, and it is good marketing, but it tells you nothing about the liquid. The liquid is sweet.

What it tastes like

Sherry casks give whiskey a particular set of flavours, and The Sexton has them clearly: dried fruit, honeycomb, dark chocolate and toasted almond on the nose. The palate is medium-full and smooth, with raisin and orange peel, a real sherry sweetness, and a nutty depth that comes straight out of the oak. The finish is long and warming, chocolate and toasted spice hanging around.

If you have had a sherried Speyside Scotch, this is in the same family of flavour, but gentler: no peat anywhere near it, and the triple distillation keeps the texture soft rather than sharp.

How to drink it

Neat in a Glencairn is the honest way to meet it. A splash of water opens the dried fruit noticeably: worth trying both ways in the same sitting. Over one large ice cube it turns into an easy winter dram.

It also makes a serious Old Fashioned. The sherry sweetness means you can cut the sugar right back, and what you get is richer and more festive than the bourbon version. In a hot toddy with lemon and honey it is very good on a cold Friday night.

Single malt against the blends

This is the comparison most people are actually making on the shelf, because the famous Irish bottles are blends, not single malts.

Bottle Style
The Sexton Single malt, sherry cask
Jameson Blended Irish
Proper No. Twelve Blended Irish
The Busker Triple Cask Triple cask blend
Writers' Tears Copper Pot Pot still and malt blend
Jameson Black Barrel (1L) Blended, heavily charred casks
Redbreast 12 Year Single pot still

A blend mixes malt whiskey with lighter grain whiskey, which is why Jameson is so easy and so consistent. A single malt keeps the malt character undiluted, so you taste the barley and the cask more plainly. Neither is better; the single malt simply has more to say. The longer version of this argument is in single malt vs blended, and the Ireland-against-Scotland question is in Irish whiskey vs Scotch.

If you want the house blends written up properly, we have guides to Jameson and to Proper No. Twelve.

The kosher question, straight

Be clear about this one, because the cask is exactly where it bites. Our listing for The Sexton records the hashgacha as uncertified, with the sherry cask flagged and rabbinic guidance recommended, and it carries no Passover certification.

Plain whiskey, grain, water, yeast, plain oak, raises few questions. A cask that previously held sherry is a different conversation, because wine residue soaked into the staves ends up in the spirit. Poskim do not all land in the same place on it. The honest position is that this is a question for your rav, not for a wine shop blog, and we would rather tell you what our listing says than paper over it. Across Irish whiskey generally, certification is thin on the ground: none of the bottles in the table above carry it.

We have written up the general principles in is your whiskey kosher. Read that, then ask your own rav about the sherry cask specifically.

Worth buying?

It is the cheapest route into Irish single malt on our shelf, and the sherry maturation means it does not drink like a cheap whiskey. If you like Oloroso-sherried Scotch but not the price of it, or you want something softer than Scotch with more character than a standard blend, this is the bottle. Browse the rest in Whiskey, or go sideways into Kosher Scotch Whisky.