The Wine Atlas

What Is American Honey? Wild Turkey's Honey Whiskey, Explained

In this guide
Golden honey dripping from a wooden dipper into an open glass jar

American Honey is Wild Turkey bourbon blended with real honey. It is a liqueur, not a straight whiskey, and it is bottled at 35.5% alcohol, which is 71 proof. That is roughly half the strength of the bourbon it is built on, and it is the single fact that answers most of what people want to know about it.

The full name on the label is Wild Turkey American Honey. It comes from the Wild Turkey Distillery in Kentucky, now part of the Campari Group, and the 750ml is on our shelf.

Is it whiskey or is it a liqueur?

Liqueur, and the distinction matters more than it sounds.

A straight bourbon has to be corn-based, barrel-aged, and bottled at 40% alcohol or higher, with nothing added. The moment you blend honey into it, you have made a liqueur, and the label has to say so. American Honey says "honey liqueur" on the bottle for exactly that reason.

What is underneath is real Wild Turkey bourbon, so the whiskey character is there. It is just carrying a lot of sweetness and sitting four and a half points of alcohol below the 40% floor a straight bourbon has to clear. If you want the difference between the categories laid out properly, we wrote bourbon vs whiskey for that.

The proof question, answered plainly

  • Alcohol by volume: 35.5%
  • Proof: 71, because American proof is simply the percentage doubled
  • A standard bourbon: 40% at the legal floor, and often higher
  • The gap: American Honey sits below the legal minimum for a straight bourbon, which is exactly why it is labeled a liqueur

People sip it neat or chilled because of that. At 71 proof it does not carry the heat of a full-strength bourbon, which is the whole reason it works on people who say they do not like whiskey.

What it tastes like

Honey first, then caramel and vanilla, then the bourbon underneath on the finish. It is sweet, and it does not pretend otherwise. The honey is real honey rather than a honey flavoring, which is why it reads as thick and floral instead of like candy.

It is good neat, better cold, and it is the easiest hot toddy you will ever build: a shot in a mug, hot water, a squeeze of lemon. On a winter Motzei Shabbos that is a two-minute drink. It also sits well next to dessert, honey cake and apple pie in particular.

The rest of the honey whiskey shelf

American Honey is the bottle that made this category normal, and it has company now. Here is what we carry, with tonight's prices:

  • Wild Turkey American Honey. 35.5%. The original, and the most bourbon-forward of the group.
  • Jim Beam Honey. 35%. Softer and rounder, more honeycomb than oak. Its page carries an OU.
  • Evan Williams Honey. 35%, 70 proof. The least expensive way into the style.
  • Bourbon Rabbi Honey Bourbon. 49%, 98 proof, finished in honey barrels with cinnamon. This one is a real whiskey rather than a liqueur, and it is certified kosher by the Bourbon Rabbi himself.

The Bourbon Rabbi bottle is the odd one out and worth understanding. The other three are bourbons sweetened down to about 35%. That one is a 98 proof bourbon finished in barrels that held honey, so the sweetness comes from the wood rather than from a blend. It drinks like whiskey, not like a liqueur.

The kosher question

Flavored whiskeys are a different conversation from straight whiskey, because once something is added to the barrel spirit there is more to check. Plain bourbon is usually straightforward. A honey liqueur has a sweetener and a flavoring in it, and that is where certification earns its keep.

So read the symbol on the bottle in your hand rather than assuming the category. Of the four above, Jim Beam Honey lists an OU, and the Bourbon Rabbi bottle is certified by its own producer. Our fuller explanation of what to look for is in is your whiskey kosher.

One thing worth saying out loud: none of these are Passover bottles. Honey liqueurs are a year-round mashke, and the Pesach shelf is a separate list.

What to pour it into

  • Neat, straight from the freezer. The cold tightens the sweetness up.
  • Hot toddy. Shot, hot water, lemon. No sugar needed, it is already there.
  • Over ice with lemonade. Long, easy, and a good way to serve it to a crowd that is not drinking bourbon.
  • In place of simple syrup in a whiskey sour. Use half American Honey and half straight bourbon and skip the sugar entirely.

The bottom line

American Honey is a 71 proof bourbon liqueur, sweet on purpose, and the reason a lot of people who swore off whiskey still have a bottle in the house. It is not a substitute for a real bourbon and it is not trying to be. The whole liqueur shelf is here, the bourbon shelf is next to it, and if you want to know where any of it sits on price, how much is a bottle of whiskey puts the numbers in order.

Free shipping on orders $150+ in the lower 48.

Related Posts

King David Sacramental Wine: A Guide to Sweet Concord Wine by the Case
King David Sacramental Wine: A Guide to Sweet Concord Wine by the Case
King David sacramental wine is one of the most widely recognized sweet Concord grape wines in North America, and it i...
Read More