What Wine Goes With Chocolate?

Wine and chocolate get put together constantly, on dessert tables, at a vort, on a Motzei Shabbos spread, and most of the time the pairing is bad. Not slightly off. Actively bad, in a way that makes the wine taste sour and metallic and the chocolate taste chalky.
It is almost always the same mistake, and it has a one sentence fix.
The only rule that matters
The wine has to be sweeter than the chocolate.
That is it. Your palate reads sweetness in relative terms. Put a dry wine next to something sweet and the wine loses all of its fruit and shows you only its acid and its tannin, which taste like sourness and bitterness with nothing to balance them. Put a sweeter wine next to the same chocolate and the fruit comes back.
Dark chocolate is also loaded with its own tannin, from the cocoa solids. Pour a young dry red over it and you are stacking tannin on tannin. The result is dry, hard and faintly bitter, which is why a serious Cabernet and a serious chocolate torte, two excellent things, make each other worse. What is tannin in wine explains the sensation if you want the mechanics.
So the dry reds on your table are not the answer here, however good they are. Dry vs sweet wine is worth a read if the labels have never made that distinction clear.
Dark chocolate: port and port style reds
This is the classic for a reason. Port is sweet, fortified and already tastes of dried fruit and cocoa, so it meets dark chocolate at full strength instead of being flattened by it.
- Porto Cordovero Fine Ruby Port is the real thing, kosher port from the Douro Valley under OU supervision. Youthful, fruit driven and the most straightforwardly correct answer on this page.
- Kedem New York State Port is the thick, dark, 18% version most people grew up with, and it is very hard to beat on a dessert table where nobody is analyzing anything.
- Katlav Ben Porat Yossef is the one to open if the chocolate is the good stuff. A fortified Cabernet from Nes Harim with six years of oak behind it.
- Or Haganuz Har Sinai is the Israeli port style benchmark, Cabernet and Merlot from the foot of Mount Meron.
What is port wine covers ruby against tawny and how long an open bottle keeps, which with port is longer than you think.
Milk chocolate: Moscato and sweet reds
Milk chocolate is sweeter, creamier and much less bitter than dark, so it does not need the heavy artillery. It needs something light, sweet and a bit fizzy to cut through the dairy fat.
- Bartenura Moscato is the obvious one and it genuinely works. Five percent alcohol, gently fizzing, sweet enough to stay standing. The 375ml half bottle is the right size if dessert is for two.
- Bartenura Asti has real sparkling pressure behind it rather than a soft fizz, and the bubbles scrub the fat off your palate between bites.
- Zion Red Moscato and Teperberg Sweet Red Moscato are the red versions, and a sweet red next to milk chocolate is one of the easiest pairings there is.
Is Moscato sweet and Moscato vs Asti vs Prosecco sort out the differences between those bottles.
White chocolate: late harvest whites
White chocolate has no cocoa solids, so there is no bitterness and no tannin to fight. What it has is cocoa butter, sugar and vanilla, and it wants a sweet white with enough acidity to stop the whole thing turning cloying.
- Herzog Late Harvest Orange Muscat brings a marmalade perfume that lifts white chocolate right off the plate.
- Herzog Late Harvest Chenin Blanc comes from Clarksburg in the Sacramento Delta, where the river fog holds the acid while the sugar climbs. That acid is exactly what white chocolate needs.
- Psagot Dessert Wine is a late harvest Chardonnay from the Judean Hills in a 500ml bottle, honeyed and apricot driven.
More of the same shelf in the best sweet white wine.
Chocolate with fruit in it
Raspberry, cherry, orange, anything in a chocolate with fruit, and the pairing changes. You now want a sweet wine with its own red fruit character to echo it rather than compete.
- Baron Herzog Jeunesse Black Muscat smells like roses and tastes like sweet berries. With a raspberry dark chocolate it is uncanny.
- Herzog Late Harvest Old Vine Zinfandel is a sweet red off old Lodi vines, concentrated enough for a cherry or orange filled chocolate.
Chocolate cake, babka and the whole dessert table
A dessert table is rarely only chocolate. There is cake, there is babka, there is fruit, somebody brought parve ice cream. You want one bottle that does not have to be matched to anything in particular.
Kedem Cream Malaga is the cheapest useful answer on this page, rich and round and made for the after dinner pour. Farbrengen Dancing Series Port is the friendly New York made port style red that gets poured at a farbrengen for the same reason.
After a fleishig meal, a cream liqueur is usually off the table. Walders Scotch and Coffee is parve, built on a non dairy base, and coffee and chocolate were always going to work. What is Walders cream liqueur has the full range, and what is chocolate liqueur covers the other direction entirely.
Serving
Chill the sweet wines properly. Around 45 to 50 degrees for Moscato and late harvest whites, a little warmer for port, around 60 to 64 degrees. A warm dessert wine tastes syrupy and a cold one tastes clean.
Pour small. Two or three ounces is a dessert pour, not a dinner pour, and these wines are rich enough that a full glass stops being enjoyable halfway down.
Serve the chocolate at room temperature. Straight out of the fridge it is waxy and most of the flavor stays locked up, which no wine can fix.
Browse the full port and dessert wine shelves, or the Moscato range for the lighter end. If you are building a pairing instinct rather than looking up one answer, wine and food pairing basics and what wine goes with cheese are the next two to read. Free shipping on orders $150+ in the lower 48.



